Benchmarking and Fierce Companions

Life of Pi – now showing

For the first 5 years of primary school, my best friend and I were in the same class. Come Grade 5 and we were abruptly separated.

As a world-crumbling-around-her 9-year-old, I begged my mother to get to the bottom of what I considered the World’s Biggest Travesty. And she did. And my best friend’s mother had asked for us to be separated. I made her first-born too competitive, apparently.

I once lived in a 5,000 person town in the US that had five supermarkets: part of me is all too convinced about the virtues of competition. And yet years ago, during a make-a-wedding-dress-from-toilet-paper hen’s night game, I callously pushed aside the fat-fingered, hideously ill-qualified “seamstresses” in my group and made the Quilton couture gown on my own. When I think of competition my first thoughts always centre on the ugliness.

While considering my primary school friendship as some kind of awful intellectual duel is a step too far for me – I always did think my friend’s mother was a hideous delusional – nevertheless, there likely was a little sparring going on. And I’m convinced it brought out the best in both of us.

Our thick-as-thieves, smart-arse-y dyad benefited from some of those things routinely overlooked when competition between women is quickly dismissed as horrible and only ever centered on men who never deserve that kind of attention.

I’ve written repeatedly about the media too often framing disagreements between woman as a catfight. The catfight frame is cheap and it’s ugly. And yet two people striving alongside one another doesn’t always have to be this way.

Benchmarking is the process whereby a person / a company / a government, compares their performance against something; a set of criteria perhaps, or a similar person or entity. The objective is to establish something to strive for, model against, learn from and perhaps even equal.

And, because it was a pretty long film, I was thinking a lot about benchmarking while watching The Life of Pi.

There’s lots of things going on with Pi that would maketh a worthwhile article: the Wizard Oz allusions, the over-explained Wizard of Oz allusions, the idea of the “unreliable narrator”, the faith.

The one thing that interested me was the relationship between Pi and the tiger, Richard Parker, and how it provided a thoroughly unexpected cinematic presentation of benchmarking.

Winnie the Pooh and Tigger too

Winnie the Pooh got it all wrong apparently: befriending a tiger is impossible. So when Young Pi (Vibish Sivakumar) found himself shipwrecked with the stripy beast, the situation was less about the duo becoming BFFs, and more so about them coming to the realisation that their sparring was essential to survival. That the battle kept them going.

Pi described Richard Parker as his “fierce companion”. He claimed that the tiger gave him something to look after, but most notably, kept him alert. Pi had to keep on his toes around the animal because tigers – not unlike pre-adolescent girls apparently – are moody creatures who snap and bite at will.

I’d like to think my friend and I had a closer relationship than Pi and Richard Parker – afterall, we had Barbies and sleepover parties – but this idea of not resting on one’s laurels, of knowing where your colleague is at – of what their standard is – can help you be a better you.

I was a better student when she was my standard; the reverse was equally true.

Yes, I’ve written about comparison being the root of all unhappiness before. And I do believe that. But equally, I think there’s something to be said for knowing what everyone’s up to; knowing what’s considered good. Because while I unquestionably hate it, good / fine / safe / happy don’t exist in a vacuum.

Join the conversation

29 Comments sorted by

  1. Mark Amey

    logged in via Facebook

    Lauren, did you and your best friend ever get back together?

    report
    1. Mark Amey

      logged in via Facebook

      In reply to Lauren Rosewarne

      Laurn, I lost my best school friend through a sequence of stupid misunderstandings. After 30 years, two divorces, and each living all over the place we are friends again, The similarities are astounding, from both being health care workers, to rekindling our love of the Gerry Anderson 'Supermarionations' to using the same electric shaver and universal remote control.

      I blame his ex girlfriend! Go on, give her a call.

      report
    2. Lauren Rosewarne

      Senior Lecturer at University of Melbourne

      In reply to Mark Amey

      The Yokos get blamed for everything ;)

      An anthology about female friendship is coming out soon - I have a chapter in it - and for reasons I still can't get my head around, my 5,000 contribution proved much more gruelling than anything I've had to write before. I guess I had happily avoided the amount of overthinking my friendships with women probably warranted, having - seemingly - directed that overthinking to relationships with men.

      report
    3. Mark Amey

      logged in via Facebook

      In reply to Lauren Rosewarne

      Yes, Lauren, it's all over-thinking. We all get worried that someone doesn't like us, is bitching about us, blah, blah, f^%$ing blah. My mind is still as suspicious, and immature as it was when I was five. Fortunately, now, in my 50s, there's another place in my mind that regularly tells me not to be so bloody precious, and just get on with life.

      report
  2. Dale Bloom

    Analyst

    Yes, I have overheard the discussions going on between various young women, and also between modern women, and it involves the most bitchy talk I have ever heard of.

    Usually talk between men includes some bonding type small talk, and then it gets down to business about who is doing what job, when do they need equipment, what tools do they need etc.

    Women’s business seems to involve bitchy gossiping about someone, and it goes on and on, and on and on, and on and on, and on and …………

    I think this is why women rarely succeed at much.

    report
    1. Mark Amey

      logged in via Facebook

      In reply to Dale Bloom

      I'll go and ask Madeleine Albright. Margaret Thatcher, Hillary Clinton and Queen Elizabeth what they think of your comments.

      report
    2. Dale Bloom

      Analyst

      In reply to Mark Amey

      A very few women, and often they were given a helping hand to get where they were, and vanished quite quickly also.

      Go onto the road at 5 am, and you will see 90% of the drivers are men.

      They are already on the job, going to work, and many have no dependant children (possibly more than 50%)

      report
    3. Mark Amey

      logged in via Facebook

      In reply to Dale Bloom

      Mate, I think that's because we're the dum ones, slogging it out every, bloody, day.

      report
    4. Dale Bloom

      Analyst

      In reply to Mark Amey

      That is true, but the country does depend on men.

      Today was an 11 hour day, yesterday was a 12 hour day, the day before was a 12 hour day, tommorrow will be perhaps a 10 hour day, and then only 4 more 12 hour days before some days off, and if it doesn't rain, I will be going to work in another town for 4 days over that weekend, and then back to this site for about 6 or more 12 hour days, before a break, and then back for 10 x 12 hour days etc.

      On and on.

      report
    5. Stephen Prowse

      CEO at Wound CRC

      In reply to Dale Bloom

      Look where highly competitive, testosterone driven chest thumping has got us!

      Think more about biology, opportunity, discrimination and outcomes.

      Cheers

      report
    6. Judith Olney

      Ms

      In reply to Mark Amey

      What constitutes success? This is a question I'm interested in. Mark you've given some examples of successful women as defined by some in our society, women who have achieved power, fame, and wealth.

      I tend to have a different view of what constitutes success, both in my own life and in the lives of those that I believe have achieved success. For example, my own Mother was a very successful woman, but she was neither wealthy or famous.

      As an artist and musician, I see success as more than…

      Read more
    7. Judith Olney

      Ms

      In reply to Mark Amey

      Exactly Mark, and to what end?

      As my Dad always said, the hearse doesn't stop at the bank on the way to the cemetery.

      Its such a waste of a life, simply slogging away at a job, particularly if the only reason to do so is to feed the consumerist economy, or trying to live up to the expectations of a society. Very inefficient use of a life and mind.

      report
    8. Dale Bloom

      Analyst

      In reply to Stephen Prowse

      Without men you would not get water from a tap, you would not get electricity, and you would not get food.

      As simple as that, but for many men, they work most of their lives, and then they give most of their money to someone else, normally their wife or children.

      I nearly fell off my chair when I read that Ita Buttrose was awarded Australian of the Year.

      The Australian Queen of Women’s Gossip Media, she was editor of a number of gossip magazines, and oversaw the destruction of vast numbers of trees to provide paper for magazines that contained the most puerile and mindless crap ever written in Australia’s history. Then she went on to appear in a number of daytime women’s gossip TV programs.

      In terms of comparing people, I would choose the men I work with to a gossip queen on any day, Australian of the Year or not.

      report
    9. John Harland

      bicycle technician

      In reply to Dale Bloom

      You work for whom, Dale? And why? Are you competing to be the most-oppressed?

      If working those hours makes you feel good, stop bellyaching. If you don't like it, don't try blaming other people.

      I would guess that your working conditions are likely set by men. If you want to blame it on women by some strange logic, I would suppose it to be because you don't dare face up to the men who are demanding that work of you.

      report
    10. Dale Bloom

      Analyst

      In reply to John Harland

      A $39 million contract, awarded by a state government for flood mitigation of roads to keep two country towns operating during heavy rains.

      About 30 years ago the roads were still dirt, and then they were sealed, and now we are building up levels and resealing them.

      It is such efforts by men to get infrastructure operating that go unnoticed and overlooked in the trendy desire to denigrate men as much as possible, and then award Australian of the Year to a gossip queen who has rarely stepped out of an air-conditioned room.

      report
    11. John Newton

      Author Journalist

      In reply to Dale Bloom

      Dale, I want to defend Ita and not just because my mother, Gloria Newton, also worked for the Australian Women's Weekly - she left just as Ita took over and did not like her at all. But to call the AWW a gossip magazine back in those days is a serious mistake.

      It was a refuge, a women's refuge from the rough hewn slab hut mutton-fuelled blokey Oz culture of the time. A place where women could read about each other, learn life skills and about the only ongoing goss was of the Royals - and yes…

      Read more
  3. Stephen John Ralph

    carer

    Hi Y'all

    friends come and go....very few stay the distance.

    I sometimes think back on the friendships I formed back in the days. People I seemed very attached to disappeared over the years....to.who knows where. (except those who died of course)

    I think we get a teensy weensy bit bored with some people and just drift away from them......some people have a few party tricks that at first seem hilarious (literally & metaphorically) at first, and then become tedious.

    Others form a romantic…

    Read more
    1. Lauren Rosewarne

      Senior Lecturer at University of Melbourne

      In reply to Stephen John Ralph

      Yeah, I blame writing a book on infidelity. Dyad stuck after that.

      That, and my fetish for descending characters. My parents evidently didn't think it necessary to give me one so clearly I'm keen to compensate :)

      report
  4. Stephen John Ralph

    carer

    Hi lauren

    wouldn't writing a book on infidelity make you favor TRIAD.

    BTW I had a later thought,rereading your article - altho it was about friendship, there were other themes perhaps ignored.

    Competitveness good and bad, and the need have friendship stimulated by differences and the aforementioned competitveness.

    report
  5. Stephen John Ralph

    carer

    Lauren

    I meant more in terms of "the other man or other woman".

    Didn't Princess Di remark - " there were three people in my marriage".

    sjr

    report
  6. John Harland

    bicycle technician

    Have you been in competition with your editor as well?

    Do you mean an "intellectual duel", rather than "dual"?

    Please, if you are going to use archaic grammar, get it right: "would maketh" just looks silly.

    Also, "vacuum" usually has two "u"s and one "c".

    Distractions that make it very difficult to concentrate on just what your key argument is.

    You seem to have glossed over the context of competition. One throwaway phrase in the middle: "knowing where your colleague is at" might better…

    Read more
    1. Lauren Rosewarne

      Senior Lecturer at University of Melbourne

      In reply to John Harland

      Thanks for your vigilance regarding spelling: the two typos have been amended.

      As for "maketh": you might not like it – and, hey, I might look silly - but that's my writing style. Ta daa!

      Cheers and thanks for reading.

      report