China’s farms pose growing antibiotic resistance risk

Unchecked use of antibiotics in Chinese farms had led to widespread antibiotic resistance, a new study has found, with researchers warning the problem may spread worldwide through manure and fertiliser run-off. China is the world’s biggest producer and consumer of antibiotics in the world, with at least…

N7k33zj7-1360622930
Widespread and unmonitored use of antibiotics in commercial Chinese pig farms may pose a risk to human health worldwide, the study said. podchef, http://www.flickr.com/photos/86571141@N00

Unchecked use of antibiotics in Chinese farms had led to widespread antibiotic resistance, a new study has found, with researchers warning the problem may spread worldwide through manure and fertiliser run-off.

China is the world’s biggest producer and consumer of antibiotics in the world, with at least 46.1% being used in livestock, as much as four times the amount used by livestock industry in the US.

Some bacteria have genes that make them resistant to antibiotics, while others can get such resistance from another bacteria. Overuse of antibiotics kills the germs with no resistance but grows the proportion of resistant bacteria in the environment.

In a study published today in the journal PNAS, researchers from the Chinese Academy of Sciences and Michigan State University analysed manure from three large scale commercial pig farms in China, looking for antibiotic resistant genes (ARGs) in bacteria.

They also tested a control sample of manure from pigs never fed antibiotics and soil from a pristine forest in Putian, China.

“We detected 149 unique ARGs among all of the [commercial farm] samples, which is three times more types of ARGs than were found in the control samples,” the researchers said in their paper, warning that the antibiotic resistant genes could spread globally and pose a human health risk.

“Microbes from manure, compost, or soil containing the ARGs are subject to dispersal via runoff into rivers, leaching to subsurface waters, air dispersal via dust, human travel, and distribution of agricultural products, including compost for gardening, which could expand a local contamination to regional and even global scales.”

The researchers also found high levels of metals such as arsenic and copper in the commercial farm samples, and theorise that the metals may be contributing to the development and persistence of antibiotic resistance.

“Policies and management tools to facilitate prudent use of antibiotics and heavy metals, including their combined use, in animal industries and animal waste management are needed,” the researchers said.

A co-author of the study, graduate student Timothy Johnson from Michigan State University, said the researchers did not test for superbugs, which are germs that are resistant to a combination of antibiotics.

“We do see that there is extensive and alarming enrichment for antibiotic resistance genes, but these genes may be spread out in many different bacteria so that individual bacteria may not be resistant to many antibiotics, or it may be the case that they are superbugs. With the data we have we just cannot say if they are superbugs or not,” he said.

Professor Matthew Cooper from the University of Queensland’s Institute for Molecular Bioscience said this type of resistance evolution had been seen before but this paper quantified it in Chinese pigs for the first time.

“If you look at the reports and many studies, there is a recognised and clear statistical link between the use of antibiotics as growth promoters and the incidence of superbugs in animals and their transfer to the human population,” said Professor Cooper, who was not involved in the study.

“That drove the European Union to ban antibiotics as growth promoters, then more recently the US has begun to ban more and more classes of antibiotics and Australia have done the same.”

The scale of the problem means that a collective approach is needed, he said.

“Let’s take the hypothesis that a country was the only country in the world that used antibiotics — that doesn’t help us at all. We need some type of framework whereby all countries standardised the practice.”

Professor Cooper called on authorities in China and India to bring in more transparent reporting measures for antibiotic use, saying that people should be very concerned by the results of this new study.

“Animals get transported between countries, as do people. Infectious disease is no longer a national issue, it’s a global issue.”

Sign in to Favourite

Want to follow The Conversation?

Sign up to our free newsletter to get the day's top stories in your inbox each morning, with a special wrap on Saturday.

Spinner
Help evidence based journalism become the norm and donate

Join the conversation

7 Comments sorted by

  1. Robert Blackham

    Property manager

    Agree that it's a problem but what can the consumer do? "Made in Australia from local and imported ingredients" tells us exactly nothing. But apparently this meaningless label is all it takes to slide past our worthless food labelling laws. It doesn't matter where it was packed, processed, "value-added", or who owns the company. None of that answers the question of where did the food come from?

    report
  2. Sharon Hutchings

    logged in via Twitter

    Excessive unhealthy consumer demand & producer greed has led to this situation, where billions of sentient animals are bred and raised in inherently cruel intensive production sheds every year across the world, including here in Australia. The growing middle classes in countries like China and India aspire to follow the harmful high animal product Western diet. Damaging to human health, the environment, and the animals. Around two thirds of the grain grown in Australia is fed to livestock and the meat & dairy industries are the most land & water intensive, and polluting. Documentaries like Food Inc. and Earthlings should be mandatory viewing for all, and should be included in our primary and secondary school curriculum. "Nothing will benefit human health and increase chances for survival of life on Earth as much as the evolution to a vegetarian diet." ~Albert Einstein

    report
  3. Trevor McGrath

    Pharmacist Hobby:climatology

    Why is China mentioned, they are only following the "science of the west". The crap that is sold in the west as 'food' would make any thinking woman trying to care for her children cringe in horror. Cheers

    report
  4. Paul Richards

    strategic foresight

    Professor Cooper called on authorities in China and India to bring in more transparent reporting measures for antibiotic ........ “Animals get transported between countries, as do people. Infectious disease is no longer a national issue, it’s a global issue.” Brilliant observation, its a global issue!
    Every single system developed countries 'sell' to China via business partnership has, and always will be a 'global issue'. It is increasingly evident the economies of scale fail to hide the deception of 'economic efficiency' vs the planets ecosystem. Since it is developed countries 'systems' taught in Universities, why are they still taught it is ok to place the environment second on the economic balance sheet?

    report
  5. wilma western

    logged in via email @bigpond.com

    This is a serious issue and cooperative US-CVhinese studies are a good way to start on tackling the problem . We do need international agreement on and enforcement of regulations re antibiotics ,definitely should be banned everywhere for growth-promotant use and strictly controlled for veterinary and human use. I remember farmers who visited the US a couple of decades ago being scandalised by anti-biotics being available in US supermarkets ( for animal use).

    report