Sections

Services

Information

UK United Kingdom

Frankenfooty: Essendon’s mixed bag of supplements

The list of charges by the AFL against the Essendon Football Club for its alleged supplements program makes for compelling reading. Early on in the Essendon charge sheet is this paragraph, which sets the…

Dr Frankenstein created a beast of horrifying power; Essendon just created a shambles. Image from shutterstock.com

The list of charges by the AFL against the Essendon Football Club for its alleged supplements program makes for compelling reading. Early on in the Essendon charge sheet is this paragraph, which sets the stage for the tragedy that is the whole doping scandal:

In or around August 2011, the Club determined to implement a scientifically pioneering program relating to the administration of supplements to its players in preparation for, and during, the 2012 AFL Premiership Season. [emphasis added]

The term Frankenfooty is a bit misleading. At least Dr Frankenstein, however misguidedly, did create a monster. In the case of Essendon, despite the lofty goals in the paragraph above, all that happened was that the players were exposed to worthless or unproven treatments at best, and rank pseudoscience at worst.

It’s important to note that Essendon has denied the charges and has called for a public hearing by an independent arbiter.

It seems Essendon’s most valuable assets, its players, were exposed to potential harmful treatments that flew in the face of the very science on which they sought to base their program.

So, what are the supplements allegedly involved, and what are they supposed to do?

Unproven drugs, not a scientific approach

Here is a short list of the drugs allegedly given to the players from the 34 page Notice of Charges (page 24-25):

  • actovegin
  • unspecified amino acids
  • unspecified multi-vitamins
  • AOD-9604 creams
  • AOD-9604 injections
  • cerebrolysin
  • colostrum
  • REDACTED (it’s blanked out in the charge list)
  • lactaway
  • lube-all-plus
  • melatonin
  • melanotan II
  • TA-65
  • thymosin beta 4
  • traumeel
  • tribulus

You can find the details on most of the drugs in this list at our Sports Drug Glossary. I’ll mention some in more detail shortly.

There are some that you won’t find in the Sports Drug Glossary. Actovegin®, an extract from calf’s serum, is suggested to improve sports performance. It is not approved for use in Australia, and has little evidence of efficacy.

TA-65 is an experimental telomerase inhibitor which might have benefits in cancer and aging, but none in sports performance.

Traumeel is a “homeopathic” herbal preparation (which actually has ingredients in it) used for treating pain and inflammation. Traumeel might possibly work, but the evidence is still weak.

The above list is not exhaustive, there were far more drugs the players were exposed to. The document alleges footballers were given infusions of vitamin C, which are worthless, and have a possibility of producing kidney stones.

The anti-Alzheimer drug cerebrolysin that appears on the AFL list might, just might, possibly reduce the possibility of brain injury, it is currently not licenced in Australia for this purpose.

Essendon players were allegedly treated with drugs that had no proven benefit. AAP Image/David Crosling

What was the “supplement protocol”?

At the centre of Essendon’s plan was a program of treatments, the supplement protocol, (first mentioned on page 12) of the following four drugs: AOD-9604, thymosin, colostrum and tribulus.

AOD-9604 and thymosin were injected: AOD-9604 weekly for the season, thymosin weekly for six weeks, then monthly.

AOD-9604 was developed as an anti-obesity drug. It is a small peptide that mimics part of the growth hormone molecule which increases fat metabolism and decreases the production of fat. AOD-9604 failed in clinical trials against obesity and there is no clinical evidence that it helps in any sports-related manner. It is not registered in Australia.

Thymosin beta-4 is a protein that binds to the cell’s cytoskeleton (which is like a cellular skeleton). It may have a role in in cell survival and the repair and regeneration of damaged tissue, but human clinical trials are limited.

It is not approved in Australia. But the sports scientist at the centre of the current saga, Stephen Dank, claims the thymosin he injected the players with was not thymosin beta-4.

Colostrum is the very early form of milk secreted late in pregnancy and in the first few days after birth. There’s little evidence that colostrum consumption (typically cow colostrum) improves team sport performance.

While not directly banned, colostrum could stimulate insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) secretion. IGF-1 is banned, but stimulation of its secretion by nutritional supplements is a grey area.

Tribulus, or rather Tribulus terrestris is a herbal medicine which is supposed to naturally increase testosterone levels. While it is popular with body builders, clinical trials have failed to show any effect of this herbal supplement on either testosterone levels or muscle development in sport.

What is the possible impact of these supplements?

I’m a toxicologist, rather than a sports scientist, but the research evidence looks rather clear.

For the drugs in the “program” (AOD-9604, thymosin, colostrum and tribulus) there is no good evidence that they do anything useful in either enhancing performance or increasing recovery from injury.

The combination of these drugs has never been tested, but given their lack of individual effects I would be surprised if they had any effect in combination.

While the individual drugs have only minor side effects reported, exposures of the duration used by Essendon have not been carefully studied in the long term, nor have combinations been studied.

Also, in the list of charges the actual concentrations of the drugs in the formulations are not reported, so it is hard to determine if the doses alleged are consistent with the few clinical trials run.

Frankenfooty or a farrago of nonsense

While Essendon started out with the goal of developing a scientific supplementation program that would push, but not break, the rules on doping, what they ended up with was a nonsense.

While the focus has been on whether or not any given supplement was allowed or banned by the rules, a far more significant point has been missed.

The charges document notes Essendon players were repeatedly treated with drugs that had no proven benefit of any kind. Any proper scientific due diligence would have pulled that up.

While the side-effects of these treatments are minor (to the extent that we know), any side-effect for a treatment that is ineffective is unwarranted. Not to mention that any injection has a slight risk of infection.

Given that the players allegedly had multiple injections, the risk to the players was compounded.

Basically it seems the players were being given risky placebos, with added pseudoscience.

Dr Frankenstein created a beast of horrifying power; Essendon just created a shambles.

Join the conversation

9 Comments sorted by

  1. Mike Brisco

    Scientist at Flinders University of South Australia

    Tribulus -

    Would that be the yellow-flowered weed Caltrop that grows on my lawn? Whose woody thumb-tack fruit, puncture my bicycle tyres every few weeks?

    Lube-All-Plus - sounds like a bicycle product .... maybe you put it on your chain, instead of oil.

    Those sports scientists are wasted in footy - the sport that really needs them, is professional cycling...

    report
    1. John Holmes

      Agronomist - semi retired consultant

      In reply to Mike Brisco

      If used to excess I suppose the effects on humans may be similar to that in sheep. Staggering with a bad case of sunburn if in the sun. That would not be a good good look for AFL.

      Time to put a bit more rigor into what is in the products being used.

      report
  2. Carly Moores

    Student

    Thank you for your article, Ian. I found it a great read in an increasingly frightening situation of circumstances. However one thing I noted is that TA-65 is actually a telomerase activator and not an inhibitor of the enzyme.

    report
  3. Janet Hiller

    Dean of Health Sciences, Faculty of Health, Arts and Design at Swinburne University of Technology

    Not just ineffective but completely unethical. Where is the duty of care? What are the occupational health and safety issues? This is not just an afl and asada matter

    report
  4. Tim Benham

    Student of Statistics

    >TA-65 is an experimental telomerase inhibitor which might have benefits in cancer and aging, but none in sports performance.

    TA-65 is extracted from Astragalus roots. A quick search on Google scholar shows that in the last few years hundreds of papers have been published reporting the positive effects of Astragalus root extracts and astragalosides on all manner of physiological systems. Approximately 100% of the authors appear to be Chinese.

    report
  5. Thomas Faunce

    ARC Future Fellow at Australian National University

    A proper governance system, before determining and implementing penalties, would have had Dank and Robinson's cross-examined testimony as to what was actually given to players and what evidence they had of whether similar programs are or have been operating at other clubs. AFL abused the rule of law here, amongst other things by tolerating conflicts of interest and in getting journalists to create a climate of hysteria to justify its 'disrepute' charges. I'm taking a break from AFL till the 2015 season. Will watch local footy instead--less betting money, commercialisation and PEDs.

    report
  6. Brian Dock

    Manager

    Oh its really nice blog and this article is very informative as it providing the latest information regarding the chemical material and its uses. Some supplements are helping the people to improvise the use of several techniques from the chemical world. As per the knowledge from the bagging of the solution with some other so that it will help you for the betterment of the society. as per the knowledge regarding several use of bags. Use of bag is becoming very famous and helpful for the people.
    http://www.xpressdupes.com/custom-bags/

    report