Killing polio workers threatens grave global consequences

The murder of nine female health workers involved in child immunisation on February 8 in Kano (the largest city in northern Nigeria) is a chilling reminder that saving children’s lives is not a goal shared by everyone. Unless such incidents are effectively prevented in countries where the poliomyelitis…

Xmz78fz5-1360555862
The Nigerian commissioner for health of Bauchi state, Dr Sani Malam (L), administers a polio vaccine to a Nigerian child during the launch of the national immunization drive in Nigeria on February 5, 2013. EPA/DEJI YAKE

The murder of nine female health workers involved in child immunisation on February 8 in Kano (the largest city in northern Nigeria) is a chilling reminder that saving children’s lives is not a goal shared by everyone. Unless such incidents are effectively prevented in countries where the poliomyelitis (‘polio’) virus still circulates, vaccination campaigns may collapse and the world may fail to eradicate this virus that causes lifelong paralysis or death.

The incident follows the murder in Pakistan of nine volunteer vaccinators (mostly women) late last year, and seven clinic workers on new year’s day. Those murders were well-planned – four of the volunteers were shot within 20 minutes in various parts of Karachi, the country’s largest city. The killings took place during a nationwide campaign to vaccinate 5.2 million children against polio.

It’s not yet clear whether the Nigerian murders were aimed specifically at the polio program given the national vaccination campaign ended on February 5. The murdered women were in the mop-up phase of vaccination, trying to immunise children who had been missed.

Smallpox is the only human disease that we’ve completely eradicated but we stand tantalisingly close to making polio the second. Nigeria, Pakistan, and Afghanistan are the only three countries in the world that have never interrupted polio transmission. In 1988, polio infection paralysed or killed 350,000 people, mainly children. Following a global eradication initiative, that number had fallen to just 222 cases last year in five countries – Nigeria (121 cases), Pakistan (58), Afghanistan (37), Chad (five), and Niger (one).

For every person paralysed or killed by polio, however, another 99 are infected who have only mild or no symptoms but can spread polio to others. This is why it’s important to vaccinate close to 100% of all children to stamp out the virus (and it’s why the campaign had a mop-up phase).

Polio is not a “tropical” disease – cases were still occurring in Australia in the 1960s. In 1952, there were 58,000 cases of paralytic polio in the United States, resulting in more than 3,000 deaths and 22,000 people left with varying degrees of paralysis.

While no-one has claimed responsibility for the killings in Nigeria, the most likely suspect is the radical Islamist group Boko Haram, which has attacked churches, government offices and police stations in the north of the country.

There’s a history of opposition to polio vaccination by certain Muslim clerics. Between 2002 and 2005, religious leaders forced the cessation of the vaccination campaign in northern Nigeria claiming the vaccines were part of a western plot to sterilise young girls and eliminate the Muslim population. As a result of the subsequent epidemic, polio was exported to 17 countries that had been polio-free.

The Abuja Declaration signed by the Nigerian president and all state governors in February 2009 signalled the start of a renewed effort for polio eradication in the country. The number of reported cases declined dramatically in the following years and the last case was reported on December 3, 2012.

In Pakistan, there has been opposition to immunisation drives in parts of the country, particularly after a fake CIA hepatitis vaccination campaign that helped to locate Osama Bin Laden in 2011.

In July 2012, the Taliban commander Hafiz Gul Bahadur issued a fatwa forbidding the vaccination of more than 200,000 children in north and south Waziristan in the country’s northwest. He was convinced that spies under the guise of medical staff would enter these areas to monitor the activities of Islamic militants.

Despite these challenges, high-level political commitment has led to significant progress in Pakistan. Polio cases dropped from 198 in 2011 to just 58 in 2012. But that progress is now threatened by the murder of polio volunteers.

The vaccination campaign was suspended in Karachi, a city of 18 million people, and as one Pakistani official told the BBC News:

Many of the roughly 80,000 field workers across Pakistan, however needy they may be, will be forced to ask themselves whether the 1,500 rupee ($15) fee they will receive for a three-day campaign is worth the risk.

In the age of fast and easy global travel, a resurgence of polio in Nigeria and Pakistan poses a threat to the entire world. The last case of polio reported in Australia was in a Pakistani student. And Nigeria has a history of exporting polio to its impoverished neighbours. In many countries that eliminated polio decades ago, vaccination rates have dropped and immunity levels are low.

Eliminating polio from its remaining reservoirs in Afghanistan, Nigeria and Pakistan may require a concerted diplomatic effort by countries with large Muslim populations, such as Indonesia and Egypt. At the 2011 Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting, the Australian government played a leading role in mobilising more than $100 million in funding for polio eradication.

Australia can also play a leading role in advocacy and use its seat in the UN Security Council to support whatever measures are needed to ensure that children in Nigeria, Afghanistan, and Pakistan are protected from this disease. By doing so, they will avert a global public health emergency, and seize the opportunity to finish the job of eradicating polio.

Sign in to Favourite

Want to follow The Conversation?

Sign up to our free newsletter to get the day's top stories in your inbox each morning, with a special wrap on Saturday.

Spinner
Become a friend of The Conversation and donate

Join the conversation

25 Comments sorted by

  1. Geoffrey Edwards

    logged in via email @gmail.com

    You have an important message. Why open with such ridculous false dichotomy?

    "a chilling reminder that saving children’s lives is not a goal shared by everyone."

    There are several factors that motivate this and which do not include indifference to the fate of children.

    "They claim that the polio campaign is conceived out of love for our children."

    "If they really love our children, why did they watch Bosnian children killed and 500,000 Iraqi children die of starvation and disease under…

    Read more
    1. Sebastian Poeckes

      Retired

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      Surely it's yet another example of people who organise their thoughts around delusions such as "invisible friends who can do magic tricks" causing totally unnecessary problems for everyone else. It isn't that they don't care for kids like we are, it's just that their heads are full of $hit.

      report
    2. Michael Toole, AM

      Professor of International Health at Burnet Institute

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      Geoffrey, all I can say is that 18 women were murdered in cold blood while administering life-saving vaccines to children. It's a stretch to imagine that their murderers care about kids. I'm not sure what these innocent and lowly paid women have to do with Bosnian and Iraqi children and multinational drug companies.

      report
    3. Geoffrey Edwards

      logged in via email @gmail.com

      In reply to Michael Toole, AM

      Andrew, If you don't know then you should probably make it your business to find out before passing comment.

      When 18 people are killed, it is not enough to skip by with facile judgements on the goals and motivations of the killers. Like Bush's "the hate us for our freedoms" BS, it doesn't wash. It is this kind of ignorance that means people keep dying.

      "It's a stretch to imagine that their murderers care about kids"

      I suggest you might want to make the effort then. You seem to need it.

      I assume the guys sitting in remote bases conducting drone strikes care about their kids? That's killing in the air conditioning via video. Cold blooded much?

      report
    4. Geoffrey Edwards

      logged in via email @gmail.com

      In reply to Michael Toole, AM

      If you like long reads, I recommend this by Adam Curtis.

      Not specific to Polio vaccination, but an intelligent man might make the connection.

      "... at its heart is a kind of filter that wipes away anything complex about power and the struggles for power in African countries - and replaces that with a simple picture of the world as divided between goodies (us in the west) and dangerous frightening baddies who are out to destroy us.

      It's both blind and arrogant. And it's terribly dangerous."

      http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/adamcurtis/posts/PARADIABOLICAL

      report
    5. Sylvia Robinson

      Archaeologist

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      Kids who need polio vaccinations are denied them because the women administering them were shot dead by islamic militants.

      report
    6. Michael Toole, AM

      Professor of International Health at Burnet Institute

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      goodies (us in the west) ???? I think the goodies are those poor women in Pakistan and Nigeria vaccinating kids to improve their lives. Geoffrey, I presume you believe that WW2 was started by aliens.

      report
    7. Phil Dolan

      Viticulturist

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      How anyone can come up with any kind of defence for the murder of people vaccinating against polio is very, very weird.

      report
    8. Geoffrey Edwards

      logged in via email @gmail.com

      In reply to Michael Toole, AM

      Michael,

      "...presume you believe that WW2 was started by aliens."

      Presume all you want. It sort of marks you out as pretty juvenile.

      I would presume that someone with so many years of experience in Africa, Asia and the pacific would have gained a more nuanced view of the world. I would be wrong.

      I would presume that people writing for the conversation might weight things in favour of academic rigor, not jouralistic flair. Also wrong.

      report
    9. Geoffrey Edwards

      logged in via email @gmail.com

      In reply to Phil Dolan

      Phil,

      I am not defending the murder of these people.

      It is false to assume that suggesting that people look deeper for the motivation for such acts is a defence of the crime. These motives are still motives that lead to the killing.

      Trying to understand Hitler, German National Socialism and the events that resulted in the atrocities of WWII is not to mount a defence. It is simply an act of learning from history.

      A failure to understand why these things happen, simply ascribing them to evil men and the vagaries of an unpredictable universe, is a failure to make the neccesary effort to avoid minimise the risk of these things happening again.

      For someone like Michael who makes the worthwhile case for vaccination, I would presume that the benefits of observation, and the application of reason to same, would be second nature.

      Instead we get facile remarks and childish rebukes of those who deign to question him.

      report
    10. Paul Richards

      strategic foresight

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      Geoffrey Edwards wrote: "Not specific to Polio vaccination, but an intelligent man might make the connection .... "
      The linking of vacination to destabilisation of developing regions is thin however. Agreed the 'testing' of many neoliberal corporate products / systems has not gone largely unnoticed in developed countries, as has their failure. Just that single issue could be discussed in an article, with comment thread of its own.
      There are many injustices with the transition from outright feudalism…

      Read more
    11. Paul Richards

      strategic foresight

      In reply to Michael Toole, AM

      Michael Toole, AM wrote; " You might be interested to read this letter from deans of schools ..... Thank you, this is consistant with the US stage of development and little surprise to read. As mentioned "Our culpability is supporting these regimes inappropriately", thank you for raising my awareness. [reference to 'stage of development' is based on Clare Graves]

      report
    12. Yoron Hamber

      Thinking

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      Think you are choosing to misunderstand him. The facts is that those killing those workers do not care about polio at all, and so neither about the children needing that vaccine, be the reasons for that what they might. It does not imply that the people living there don't love their kids.

      We humans are weird that way, give us a political or ideological view and we easily suppress our innate understanding of our common humanity, replacing it with them and us.

      Think it has to do with education myself, education about the world and people living in it. Although it's no guarantee of anything.

      report
  2. Peter Ormonde

    Peter Ormonde is a Friend of The Conversation.

    Farmer

    The decision to use a fake medical campaign to track down Osama might have seemed simple and convenient - but the damage done to aid programs in countries where there is a fundamentalist challenge is to put aid workers - foreign aid workers in particular - right in the firing line.

    This use of foreign aid - medical programs in particular - should never be allowed to happen again. Such deception should be outlawed under the Geneva Convention or some other more suitable agreement covering military conduct. This gets good people killed. This gets children maimed by disease.

    Utterly outrageous.

    report
  3. Greg Boyles

    Lanscaper and former medical scientist

    Wouldn't have anything to do with the fact that the stupid yanks used a polio vaccination team as a means of gaining entry to Osama Bin Laden's compound to confirm his presence before sending in the strike team????

    report
    1. Geoffrey Edwards

      logged in via email @gmail.com

      In reply to Greg Boyles

      This Guardian article suggests that the cover program was for Hep B. Apparently the kids in the compound had already received polio shots.

      "The doctor went to Abbottabad in March, saying he had procured funds to give free vaccinations for hepatitis B. Bypassing the management of the Abbottabad health services, he paid generous sums to low-ranking local government health workers, who took part in the operation without knowing about the connection to Bin Laden. Health visitors in the area were among the few people who had gained access to the Bin Laden compound in the past, administering polio drops to some of the children."

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vaccinations-osama-bin-ladens-dna

      I guess the devil himself, Osam Bin Laden, was not opposed to saving children's lives.

      report
    2. Greg Boyles

      Lanscaper and former medical scientist

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      A Four Corners report on this said that the vaccination team was a polio one.

      Let's not forget that the 'devil' as you call him was 'made in the USA'....not that I am a member of the Osama Bin Laden fan club.

      report
    3. Peter Ormonde

      Peter Ormonde is a Friend of The Conversation.

      Farmer

      In reply to Geoffrey Edwards

      I suspect that such subtle distinctions - as between hep and polio - are lost on these fellas Geoff.

      All they see is white coats, foreigners and the 21st century trying to intrude itself into their feudal world view. It's all part of the Grand Western Conspiracy against Muslims.

      It has just opened up another line of attack - a pretext for seeing aid workers - in health or other fields - as "legitimate targets".

      A disgracefully irresponsible thing to have done.

      report
    4. Greg Boyles

      Lanscaper and former medical scientist

      In reply to Greg Boyles

      You know I often wonder if the good old USA is more part of the problem of global terror and vaccination team assinations etc than it is part of the solution!

      report
    5. Greg Boyles

      Lanscaper and former medical scientist

      In reply to Peter Ormonde

      Or more US miliatry operatives mounting some political operation in the neighbourhood now that the US military imbeciles have set this precedent.

      report