No one state for water catchments

New research has developed understanding of how water catchments react to natural disturbances in relation to wet and dry years.

The work shows that in some catchments, after a wet year the stream flow and water table do not always return to their previous state as has been traditionally assumed.

The research also discusses how catchment resilience can be measured, which could lead to more informed decisions about water resourcing.

Read more at University of Melbourne

Join the conversation

5 Comments sorted by

  1. Caroline Copley

    student

    Hmm, from what I have read of chaos theory which is probably not enough, a system may start off as random but quickly becomes bifurcated into two "strange attractors", and then continues on into a chaotic state (which may display considerable order). I have therefore often thought as a biologist that the wet-dry cycles of wetlands, especially those associated with rivers, were bifurcated in such a way.
    The Murray is so highly disturbed as to be almost unrecognisable but nevertheless the wet…

    Read more
    1. David Arthur

      n/a

      In reply to Caroline Copley

      Good points, Carol.

      I understand your remarks as essentially suggesting that the historic input pattern of 'good' and 'bad' years is certainly driven by chaotic climatic fluctuations, so that couple of biotic suites ('guilds') could emerge, with each such 'guild' adapted to a particular climatic mode. With the establishment of this pattern of relative predominance, the biota observed each year thereafter will reflect dominant climatic mode.

      Is my understanding correct?

      report
    2. Caroline Copley

      student

      In reply to David Arthur

      Eventually sorted my email to get back to you, sorry!
      Yes I think there is probably some evidence that the aquatic scientists could give you which would be a strong indication of guilds or associations that vary with stage of cycle, and they may have already defined something similar (its not my field). If so, this would allow a basically bifurcated pattern under different cyclic pressures that may correspond to one you could additionally find in the main river. Alternatively if a billabong…

      Read more
  2. Caroline Copley

    student

    Sorry I found the article which it says "In press" and clearly this is mathematically based so I am not telling you anything new probably, and seems to involve attractors already. However in the real world of ecology (!) which is complexity unlimited for those that like a challenge, there are possibly some great examples, such as wetlands that are ephemerally dry, where your sophisticated model has real meaning. For validation in real catchments my message still stands about needing to take into…

    Read more
  3. Caroline Copley

    student

    When I said "my studies" on soil carbon I was referring to the fact I have recently been reading numerous papers on it, and they show that as in Hubbard Brook, vegetation and nutrient loads and moisture are intimately linked. However aside from that for one essay I did do a bit of an analysis of deserts, in which I calculated biomass and soil carbon for a range of arid areas. This was based on Bastin (2011), which gathered productivity values across Australia between the period 2001-2012 thus…

    Read more