Recession hits Māori and Pasifika harder. They must be part of planning New Zealand's COVID-19 recovery
Tahu Kukutai, University of Waikato, Helen Moewaka Barnes, Massey University, Tim McCreanor, Massey University, Tracey Mcintosh
As schools and businesses reopen and attention shifts to the longer-term repercussions of the COVID-19 pandemic, it is critical that Māori be involved in decision making more equitably than has so far happened.
The failure to include Māori in strategy discussions throughout the pandemic has already been roundly criticised, most recently over tangihanga (funeral) restrictions and the Public Health Response bill, which sets up a new legal framework for responding to COVID-19.
Māori public health specialists have repeatedly challenged a one-size-fits-all approach to pandemic recovery. There is also growing unease about who has the authority to make decisions in the best interests of Māori collectives. The sidelining of Māori as Te Tiriti (Treaty of Waitangi) partners cannot continue through our recovery and rebuild.
First do no harm
As restrictions are relaxed under level 2, it is Māori and Pacific communities that carry a higher risk – both to their health and livelihoods.
Emerging international evidence also suggests the social and economic impacts of the pandemic will be felt for longer and more intensely for people living in precarious conditions – more likely to be racial minorities.
In Aotearoa we know previous economic recessions hit Māori and Pacific communities hardest, with consequences across generations. Even with the government’s NZ$50 billion COVID-19 budget plan, one Treasury forecast says unemployment will peak nationally at 9.6% in June this year.
Māori unemployment was nearly this high even before the pandemic (8.2% in the March quarter) and economists predict levels will surge over the next two years.
Unsurprisingly, last week’s budget was firmly focused on job creation. Among the suite of investments, NZ$900 million was earmarked for specific Māori initiatives, including $NZ136 million for the Whānau Ora programme and a NZ$200 million Māori employment package that includes boosting youth employment.
These will help address short-term employment needs in the most affected regions. But the opportunity to take a long-term transformational view that enables Māori to thrive, not merely survive, was lost.
Local decision making is vital
While there is immense pressure to fast-track economic recovery, the risk is that responses designed by and for largely Pākehā (non-Māori) constituencies will maintain, or deepen, pre-existing inequities.
Decisions must be based on evidence – but evidence takes many forms. New Zealand should draw on its dual knowledge systems: the richness of mātauranga Māori – Māori knowledge and ways of knowing – and “western” science. Now more than ever we need diverse sources of expertise, experience and leadership.
Over the past month, iwi (tribal groups) and Māori communities have demonstrated a remarkable capacity to anticipate and respond to the needs of their people – from setting up checkpoints to protect vulnerable and remote communities, to providing online support for grieving whānau (families) and delivering care packages to elders.
Indigenous communities in Aotearoa and elsewhere demonstrate powerful distributed leadership and a deep capacity to care for each other, based on the strength and knowledge of kin and kin-like connections.
These adaptive capacities have always existed within Te Ao Māori (Māori worldview). The pandemic placed them in the full view of mainstream New Zealand. Māori communities have strong social networks and infrastructures (especially marae – tribal meeting places) and long experience of dealing with the impacts of ongoing colonialism, natural disasters, pandemics, and mass death.
With worldviews that are inherently long-term and holistic, Māori are well positioned to lead circular economies. Māori models of regenerative agriculture and ecotourism can help shape a globally distinctive Indigenous sector that puts inter-generational and environmental well-being first.
We can learn from such examples and build this evidence systematically into our response with co-determined strategies and solutions.
Reimagining our futures beyond coronavirus
As te Tiriti or a treaty partner, the government has an important role to play. But everyone will lose out if Māori and Pacific community agency and local solutions are not used.
By re-imagining our futures we can address unjust and unsustainable inequities. An unrelenting and system-wide focus on equity is clearly needed. We also need to amplify and support what is strong including a respectful treatment of te taiao (environment) and mana motuhake (self-governance, autonomy) in diverse communities and households.
Our youthful Māori and Pacific populations are a demographic gift. It must not be squandered in the post-COVID-19 reset. Ongoing investment in their potential will not only benefit wider and future whānau, it will also future-proof regional economies.
If the pandemic has taught New Zealanders anything it is that our well-being as individuals is intimately connected to the well-being of those around us and our environments.Comment on this article
Tahu Kukutai is Professor of Demography at the National Institute of Demographic Analysis, University of Waikato. She is a co-opted member of the Chief Science Advisor Forum, incoming Co-director of Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga, a founding member of the Māori Data Sovereignty Network Te Mana Raraunga, a technical advisor to the Data ILG and a research advisor to FOMA-Innovation.
Helen Moewaka Barnes is a Professor and Co-director of the SHORE & Whariki Research Centre, College of Health, Massey University. She is Co-theme Leader, Te Tai Ao, Nga Pae o te Maramatanga and is affiliated with A Better Start, National Science Challenge. She is an advisor on the Whakatika Research Project, Ta Atawhai o te Ao. She has received funding from the Health Research Council of New Zealand, The Marsden Fund, Ministries, NGOs and other public funders.
Tim McCreanor is a professor of public health at SHORE & Whariki Research Centre of Massey University in Auckland. As a senior Pakeha researcher within Whariki he has a public profile on the social determinants of health with a particular focus on racism, colonisation, disparities and their health and wellbeing impacts. He has received funding from NZ Health Research Council, Marsden Fund and other public funders.
Tracey Mcintosh is affiliated with University of Auckland. Professor of Indigenous Studies and Co-Head of Wānanga o Waipapa (School of Māori Studies and Pacific Studies); Chief Science Advisor, Ministry of Social Development; sat on expert advisory groups including the Welfare Expert Advisory Group (2018-2019), Te Uepū Hāpai i te Ora (Safe and Effective - Justice Advisory Group (2018-2019), Expert Advisory Group on Solutions to Child Poverty (2012). Currently sit on Criminal Cases Review Commission Establishment Advisory Group; Co-Chairing the Office of the Prime Minister's Chief Science Advisor Cannabis in Aotearoa New Zealand.