Menu Close
An elderly man in white robes is seen waving at throngs of people from a vehicle that surrounds him in protective glass.
Pope Francis arrives to a hero’s welcome at Commonwealth Stadium in Edmonton on July 26, 2022, to take part in a public mass. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette

I survived the ’60s Scoop. Here’s why the Pope’s apology isn’t an apology at all

Pope Francis came this week to Maskwasic in central Alberta — where many Indigenous people, including survivors of residential schools and their descendants, had gathered — to deliver an expected apology in response to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Call to Action No. 58:

We call upon the Pope to issue an apology to Survivors, their families, and communities for the Roman Catholic Church’s role in the spiritual, cultural, emotional, physical, and sexual abuse of First Nations, Inuit, and Métis children in Catholic-run residential schools.

I am the granddaughter of a Residential School survivor. I am the daughter of a First Nations woman who survived having each of her seven children stolen and relocated through the ’60s Scoop assimilation policy.

Read more: Forced sterilizations of Indigenous women: One more act of genocide

I spent more than 25 years searching for and locating not only my birth mother, but also all of my siblings who were spread across several provinces. I continue to fight to ensure that my nieces, nephews and young relatives know who they are — and that we are here because of the undeniable strength and perseverance of our ancestors.

What many Canadians don’t understand is that the struggles within Indigenous communities today are not cultural traits — they are symptoms of a people still struggling from the intergenerational trauma and horrors experienced through the genocidal acts and abuses that took place through the Residential School assimilation policy.

Is the papal apology genuine?

Did the Pope’s apology truly address Call to Action No. 58?

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission called for the apology to take place on Turtle Island within one year of the release of the 2015 report. It also called for the apology to speak to the role of the Roman Catholic Church.

Seven years later, and only due to the consistent persistence of Indigenous Peoples, Pope Francis agreed to apologize. But what did he apologize for?

Read more: Pope’s long-awaited apology for Indian Residential Schools in Canada is a ‘first step’

Much like he did when an Indigenous delegation visited Rome earlier this year, Pope Francis apologized for “the ways in which many members of the church and religious communities co-operated” in the Residential School system.

This was not the Catholic Church taking responsibility for acts of genocide and spiritual, emotional and physical abuses. Apologizing for individuals versus the establishment that upheld not only the assimilation policy, but also protected — and continues to protect — the people who committed the crimes is horrifying at worst and an insult at best.

The Catholic Church not only upheld the government’s Residential School system, it used it to further its own religious agenda. It continues to protect Catholic officials who perpetrated criminal acts upon the children. Some of them are still alive to this day.

Canada continues to investigate and hold accountable individuals who committed war crimes during the Second World War. Where is the accountability for those who have committed crimes against Indigenous children?

A woman holds a red banner with hundreds of names on it.
A person holds a banner with the names of children who died in Residential Schools at Pope Francis’s appearance in Maskwacis, Alta., on July 25, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson

Other areas where the church falls short

After the discovery of unmarked graves of children who died while attending Residential Schools began receiving international coverage in 2021, the Catholic Church committed to providing $30 million to support reconciliation projects for survivors.

Read more: 'Every child matters': One year after the unmarked graves of 215 Indigenous children were found in Kamloops

But its fundraising campaign fell short by nearly 90 per cent. The church claims it’s still working on a detailed plan.

Nonetheless, in 2016 it managed to raise and invest $128 million to renovate St. Michael’s Cathedral Basilica in downtown Toronto.

The Catholic Church is among the wealthiest religious organizations in the world. Money flows where priorities go, and the Catholic Church clearly prioritizes renovations over reconciliation.

Signs printed with the names of Residential School victims are tied to the iron gates surrounding a cathedral.
Signs printed with the names of Residential School victims are tied to the gates outside St. Michael’s Cathedral Basilica in Toronto in April 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Yader Guzman

Indigenous groups, including the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation, have also been calling for the release of all Residential School records since the release of the 2015 Truth and Reconciliation Commission report. But the Vatican still hasn’t complied.

It holds records and requires Indigenous people to travel to Rome to access the documents. There are also suspicions some documents have been destroyed.

False absolution causes pain

I would not be walking in my truth if I were not to acknowledge how the church has manipulated some Indigenous people.

It appears that the church feels its only responsibility was to listen to survivors share their stories of horror, and that in itself absolves it of any wrongdoings and releases it from any further accountability.

This is still being acted out today in ways that are extremely upsetting for me and many other Indigenous people. We saw it this week as the Pope was gifted sacred items from those who suffered abuses.

Sharing of gifts is a cultural norm for Indigenous Peoples. But to share sacred, ceremonial items that are intended to acknowledge people at the highest level for their contributions, wisdom and leadership is not only inappropriate, it’s deeply harmful for Indigenous culture and the future of our young people. Neither the Pope nor the church has earned these gifts.

A man in a white robe straightens and Indigenous headdress on his head.
Pope Francis puts on an Indigenous headdress during a meeting with Indigenous communities in Maskwacis, near Edmonton, on July 25, 2022. (AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia)

It suggests that we don’t deserve reparations, accountability or reciprocity.

Time and time again, Indigenous people who have been displaced through assimilation policies and other colonization tactics tell me they profoundly desire opportunities to learn more about who they are, where they come from and to understand our cultures.

I have wiped their tears while they cry when they see Indigenous political leaders give away headdresses, pipes and drums as symbolic, performative gestures to those who continue to harm us.

Reconciliation requires people to act

To my relatives still struggling as you are finding your way back into the circle, I extend my deepest sympathies for the hurt you endured as you watched this happen again during the Pope’s visit. These behaviours must end, full stop.

To the broader community of people in Canada, know that reconciliation is not solely the responsibility of the state or an institution. It also falls upon the individual.

Reconciliation is how you guide conversations with your family while having dinner. It’s how you acknowledge the Pope’s apology and how you deepen the discussion to talk about what wasn’t said. It’s those conversations that will contribute to a future where everyone in Canada can thrive, including Indigenous Peoples.

Want to write?

Write an article and join a growing community of more than 179,000 academics and researchers from 4,896 institutions.

Register now