More effort should be directed towards preventing the uptake of cannabis by young people argue US researchers, after a study of more than 1,000 New Zealanders found it could cause memory loss and drops in IQ scores by mid-adulthood.
The study, which followed the participants until age 38, found those that started using cannabis in adolescence and continued to use it experienced a greater IQ decline compared with adult-onset users.
In their paper, published in PNAS, Madeline Meir and colleagues write that quitting or reducing cannabis use did not fully restore neuropsychological functioning among that same group, suggesting that taking up cannabis in adolescence when the brain is undergoing critical development, could have neurotoxic effects.
“Adolescence is a particularly critical period of brain development and maturation,” said Nadia Solowij, Associate Professor and ARC Future Fellow in the School of Psychology at University of Wollongong.
“As such, it may be more vulnerable to insult from drugs than the more mature adult brain.”
While evidence has been accumulating for impaired function in both adult and adolescent samples, Professor Solowij said evidence for ongoing impairment after cessation of use has been mixed.
“This study was able to rule out a range of potential confounds that are often suggested to underlie reports of adverse effects on cognitive function in cannabis users.”
The study’s findings add to the case for preventive public health education to reduce adolescent initiation and use of cannabis, said Professor Wayne Hall, NHMRC Australia fellow deputy director at The University of Queensland Centre for Clinical Research.
Professor Hall said in the past it has been difficult to decide whether cannabis was the cause of cognitive impairment, or cognitively impaired young people were more likely to become involved in regular cannabis use.
“This prospective study greatly strengthens the case for regular cannabis use being a cause of cognitive decline by mid adulthood in young people.”
Robin Murray, Professor of Psychiatric Research, at, Kings College in London, said we have known for some time that heavy use of cannabis increases risk of schizophrenia-like psychoses.
“There are far fewer studies on its effect on minor psychiatric illness or on everyday life. However, there are a lot of clinical and educational anecdotal reports that cannabis users tend to be less successful in their educational achievement, marriages and occupations…This study provides one explanation as to why this might be the case.”
Matthew Albrecht
Postdoctoral Researcher at Curtin University
Why are links rarely ever used to link directly to the articles, especially on a site like this. For those interested - http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/08/22/1206820109.abstract
Charis Palmer
News Editor at The Conversation
Oops, that was an oversight. The link has now been added.
Brett Twentythree
Typer
"Young people"?
Did you not think it worth mentioning that the study was on 13 year olds?
Peter Reynolds
logged in via Facebook
The vital and important point about this study is that it sheds light, yet again, on the appallingly irresponsible policy of prohibition. Our government is failing entirely to provide any protection to our children against cannabis dealers. All the evidence is that where cannabis is legally available to adults through a properly regulated system, use by children falls and age at first use increases. Any psychoactive substance can be harmful to the developing brain. The equivalent results with alcohol would be much more damaging. Professor Terrie Moffitt, from the Institute of Psychiatry, said: Its such a special study that Im fairly confident that cannabis is safe for over-18 brains, but risky for under-18 brains. Cannabis is safe for adults.
CLEAR published independent, expert research last year which shows that a tax and regulate policy on cannabis would produce a net gain to the UK economy of up to £9.3 billion per annum.
Daniel Kinsman
logged in via Twitter
For those interested, regular use is defined in the study as using cannabis 4 or more days per week.
Robert Tony Brklje
retired
A quick read of the report finds it pretty poor for two reasons.
Firstly no investigation of alcohol use during that same period by those same persons, for the obvious reason that alcohol has well known deleterious affects.
Secondly, profession and hobbies, use it or lose it, has been well proven with regard to maintaining mental acuity as one ages.
So it seems very much like a distorted report, specifically designed to achieve a preferred result by making absolutely no effort to remove two well documented causes of mental deterioration over time.
Very poor science indeed.
Danny Hoardern
Analyst Programmer
What gets me is the portion of the tax we pay that fails to stop adults from consuming pot (at most they will stop one source, you can always get it from someone else, and usually the case is your regular supplier can get it from somewhere else).
It doesn't matter what studies are put out, adults will still consume pot, just as the earth will spin. We would have more success at eradicating obnoxious weeds or cane toads.
Separate studies for alcohol exist with similar results, but in a way it is good for them to focus on cannabis - it draws political attention because our government (hopefully) knows that regulation and enforcing regulation is a smarter approach to keeping pot away from adolescents.
Some reading material: http://healthland.time.com/2011/07/19/study-marijuana-not-linked-with-long-term-cognitive-impairment
Danny Hoardern
Analyst Programmer
I completely trust the black market will check the IDs of younger people and not sell to them if they're under age. If we regulate cannabis all we do is take away money from those that profit from selling weeds. Do we really want to take money from these people? Of course not. I guarantee you that an unregulated drug is safer than a regulated drug.
Oh wait what was I smoking...
Once we regulate we can have current law enforcement efforts focus on enforcing age restrictions instead of wastefully spending our tax money trying to stop adults from consuming pot.
Sue Ieraci
Public hospital clinician
Rather than an ideologically-driven "this drug is worse than that one" argument, why don't we try an "all hazards" approach:
The use of ALL mind-altering substances that affect behavaviour, brain development and judgement in the immature brain should be minimised until brain development has a chance to mature (early twenties, they say).
How about this:
Children and teens: minimal or no alcohol, tobacco, cannabis, sedatives, petrol sniffing, ecstasy, caffeinated drinks (?)
Adults: take responsiblity for own actions, work towards laws reflecting potential harm.
Danny Hoardern
Analyst Programmer
Adults making their own decisions about what they put in their body? Sounds good!
Sue Ieraci
Public hospital clinician
Selective reading, Danny.
"Taking responsiblity for own actions" and working towards altering laws is not quite the same as "do whatever you like"....
Danny Hoardern
Analyst Programmer
Indeed Sue, thank-you for pointing this out. Harm reduction should be our number one priority, closely followed by smart fiscal policy - we need to be able to afford the important things like better health-care.
Scrapping an ineffective and expensive prohibition can only help (not so much reducing spending; re-allocating police resource resources to more important matters).
I know of the horrors you guys go through with the prevalence of alcohol. After we have legalised cannabis and have…
Read moreSue Ieraci
Public hospital clinician
Thanks, Danny - I'm with you on harm reduction and "penalty in proportion to harm".
Roger Crook
Retired agribusiness manager & farmer
Don't suppose the world has changed much in the last six or seven years?
Table 7. Top Cash Crops in the United States (Average Value 2003 – 2005)
Average
Rank
Crop
Production
Value ($1000s)
1
Marijuana
$35,803,591
2
Corn
$23,299,601
3
Soybeans
$17,312,200
4
Hay
$12,236,638
5
Vegetables
$11,080,733
6
Wheat
$7,450,907
7
Cotton
$5,314,870
8
Grapes
$2,876,547
9
Apples
$1,787,532
10
Rice
$1,706,665
11
Oranges
$1,583,009
12
Tobacco
$1,466,633
13
Sugarbeets
$1,158,078
14
Sugarcane
$942,176
15
Sorghum
$840,923
16
Cottonseed
$821,655
17
Peanuts
$819,617
18
Barley
$653,095
19
Peaches
$474,745
20
Beans
$467,236
How do you 'control' an industry is big as big as that?
Danny Hoardern
Analyst Programmer
You can't Roger, the Mars mission is just a hoax, as with everything we've been spoonfed relating to humans being able to accomplish anything. Humans inventing of the TV? Fake, aliens did it. Humans inventing breakfast cereal? Fake, aliens did it. Humans inventing the lightbulb? Obviously fake, aliens did it. That device you're using to interface with the Internet? Yup.