There are many people who would like us to believe that sport and politics should never mix. The reason for this is sport is seen as the pure and noble practice where champions arrive after hard work and application and chancers and cheats are found out.
Politics is seen as grubby and cynical, where body blows become part of the national discussion and big decisions come with small movements of the policy makers pen.
But sport and politics have always been entangled. To take one from the other would be like taking a mother out of motherhood. Impossible and implausible.
This is something Indigenous Australian boxer and Olympian Damien Hooper found out when he chose to wear an Indigenous flag t-shirt into the ring.
The Cathy Freeman lesson
Sport enables us to see the over-lapping themes of race and history. When Cathy Freeman cloaked herself in the Aboriginal flag at the 1994 Commonwealth Games it created a furore in the Australian media. Many commentators claimed that Freeman should have refrained, because Aboriginal Australia is not recognised as a self-governing nation.
As historian Colin Tatz put it, “Those who deplored her ‘un-Australian’ behaviour have no understanding of Aboriginal history.”
What he meant is that media commentators failed to acknowledge that no Indigenous Australian has ever formally signed an agreement that they have “given up” their land to anyone.
To put this another way, the Mabo decision in 1992 proves that Indigenous peoples and societies were here before 1788. For many non-indigenous Australians this is a concept that they do not or cannot acknowledge and so indifference becomes the way of handling (un)reality.
Football and race
In the late 1980s the West Coast Eagles came into the AFL, along with Indigenous players like Phil Narkle, Wally Matera and Chris Lewis. The “complexion” of the AFL really started to change.
This also brought more supporter hostility with it, culminating in the famous round four fixture between St Kilda and Collingwood in 1993 when Nicky Winmar raised his jumper to a hostile Collingwood football crowd. At the time, Winmar could not have conceived of what the outcome of his action would have been. For the broader community it began the process of sparking great debate about racism in football and society.

Then Collingwood President Allan McAlister said at the time that Winmar and team mate Gilbert McAdam would be respected “as long as they conducted themselves like white people.”
The reason Winmar’s stance has transcended the realm of sport is the power of its message. “You cannot ignore me anymore”, it demands.
Tennis, anyone?
Evonne Goolagong, was perhaps the most internationally famous Indigenous sportsperson in Australia before Cathy Freeman. During the 1980 Wimbeldon tournament, a senior Australian politician at the time said he hoped she “wouldn’t go walkabout like some old boong”.
But she played tennis so well that people forgot her colour. Did this make her any less Indigenous? Of course not, it just added to the rich tapestry of the way we all engaged with and celebrated “our” diversity in sport.
Vox nullius
Which brings us to Indigenous Olmpian Damian Hooper and the issue of his t-shirt. The echoes of Cathy Freeman ghosted his actions. But they also are ghosted by the defiance of Dawn Frazer, Cassius Clay, Tommie Smith and John Carlos.
Why? Because all were fighting to speak out against oppression and a system that does not want to recognise them. In this way it is not just a case of terra nullius in Australia – a legacy we are still dealing with – but also vox nullius – no voice.
Don’t believe me?
If I said I have a world-class athlete who does not drink or smoke, is very religious, has a wife and family and works hard when he is not competing you would possibly reply positively. If I then said “Anthony Mundine”, many opinions would turn negative. I have done this test on many classes of mine and I have asked people why is this the case. The vast majority say because they hate what he says and what he thinks.
Fair enough. I too don’t agree with many things Mundine says but I will defend to the death his right to say it. I ask them about issues of free speech and agency. What they mean for different people and how much they are valued by us all.
The reason why people react negatively because their perspectives also come with a legacy: that being the notion that Indigenous people needing to know their place. To be seen and not heard. To speak when spoken to, to perform when the bell rings or the starters gun goes.
In the land of the fair go and being dinky-di, let us truly embrace what that means. Good luck Damien Hooper and bring back the gold.
Philip Dowling
IT teacher
I find it puzzling that Doug Nicholls and Polly Farmer to name but two household names have not been mentioned.
The Ella brothers in rugby union and Arthur Beetson in rugby league are "giants" of the game that have been omitted.
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Philip it is a good point but it is a piece on the Olympics hence the lack of input from localised football codes in the story.
Heaveho.
Sean
Philip Dowling
IT teacher
Sean,
I am so sorry. I didn't know that Phil Narkle, Wally Matera and Chris Lewis and Nicky Weimar were Olympic competitors.
What sports pray tell ?
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Phil me old China - I am aware of all the people you mentioned - how could I not? Sadly the word count does not permit the opening up of the shoulders - so to speak - no-one was 'omitted' and the lack of the 'mention was done due to the count. A 10 count you might say. Enjoy the Olympics and relax its just a game....!
Anthony Nolan
Ruminant
If you want to know about First Australians in Aussie sport read Tatz, mate.
Anthony Nolan
Ruminant
Which comment was directed to Dowling not you Sean.
Colin
logged in via Twitter
Interesting, and it made me reconsider the way I look at the actions of people (with Mundine being a perfect example).
It does make me sad though how quickly and meekly Hooper backed down about though. I find it hard to imagine that he didn't know exactly what he was doing. While Mundine's arrogant, in-your-face approach irritates me a lot, it gets my attention.
Anthony Nolan
Ruminant
Hooper made his point and then withdrew before the Olympic bureaucracy had the opportunity to crunch him; make no mistake, they would have done.
This left Mundine to make the political case which he has done, vigorously and in forthright terms. I don't have any problem at all with either the content or delivery of Mundine's message. I reckon he embodies many Australian virtues not least of which is a willingness to stick it up the establishment. Now we can all sit back and watch apologists for racism stumble spluttering their usual nonsense.
I enjoyed watching Mundine flog Danny Green in the 'race fight', for such was the MSM treatment of the match. Even more than the way he whipped Green, I enjoyed the way that Green's redneck supporters expressed their disappointment at the result, in the hotel where I watched the fight, by beating the living bejeezuz out of each other.
Hats off to Aboriginal sportsmen and women who wear their flag and identity with pride.
Sean Lamb
Science Denier
There are hundreds of micro-nationalities across the world with varying rights to legitimacy - some of which have caused much bloodshed and suffering across the world. The IOC has better things to do than work through those that are uncontroversial and besides it creates precedents.
Let Hopper wear his Aboriginal flag - without permission - and what is to stop a Sri Lankan Tamil wearing their preferred colours? A Transylvanian Hungary wearing Hungarian colours? A Turkish Kurd wearing Kurdish colors? Indonesians wearing West Papua colours? Some or all of these may have valid claims, it is just not the job of the IOC to adjudicate on such issues.
If Australia really thinks it OK they need to ask the IOC if it can be recognised as a variant Australian uniform.
Anthony Nolan
Ruminant
Shorn,
The Australian branch of the IOC won't request that the Aboriginal flag be recognised becsause the Australianbranch of the 'Olympic family' is dysfunctional, racisist, inbred and pure hicksville when it comes to the subtleties of democracy and cultural recognition.
The Sri Lankan flag no more represents Tamils than the Turkish flag represents Kurds or the flag of 'Team GB' represents the Scots and the Welsh. But you'd rather have your Olympic family delusions unsullied by historical or current social reality, wouldn't you?
Anthony Nolan
Ruminant
Racisist, of course, being a severe casesist of racism.
Sean Lamb
Science Denier
Sure the Australian Olympic Committee are a bunch of dysfunctional, racists, inbred hicks and in no way measure up to the enlightened brilliance and sweet reason and compassion of an Anthony Nolan.
All I am saying is it is not the role of the IOC to investigate and adjudicate on all those issues.
As for whether the Sri Lankan flag represents Tamils or not, I really couldn't care less. If they don't like the patten, don't compete. For my part I couldn't care what coloured rag represents Australia, for me it is has no bearing on what Australia is about.
Comment removed by moderator.
Sean Lamb
Science Denier
Get with the Olympic spirit, Mr Nolan, winners are grinners.
The Tamils will just have to find some way to progress their social development that doesn't involve suicide bombs and guns.
Dan Fashaw
Brain Surgeon
A uniform is a uniform and he knew he was going to have to wear it at the Olympics when he competed.
He could always express is cultural identity through other ways. It's not racist to expect that an Australian wear the Australian uniform. If people think they shouldn't have to wear it then don't compete.
The fact is people will roar to his defence and say there should be two colours just so they can sit on the moral high ground.
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Dan - fair cop but what other way could he express that cultural identity? can you give us an example?
darryl coulstock
registered nurse
He was not there to express his cultural identity. Here was there like all peoples from australia who have non-white australian heretage. that was to participate in a world wide sporting event representing thier countries that they live in. by all means be proud of who you are but dont hijack what is meant to bring people together in friendship in a world torn apart by violence. that is wrong! and sean, if you cannot think of other ways for someone to express thier identity in a positive way then you need far more work in research. his actions does not do his cause benefit.
Gary Myers
logged in via LinkedIn
The dot stylings of Aboriginal art are well known and a shirt emphasizing those would have done the job without breaching the promises made as part of his agreement to participate in the Olympics.
He could have even had red shorts and a black top with a yellow sun on it.
The problem is that a flag represents a political opinion, not simply one of cultural identity.
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Darryl, if one cannot ask a question of someone else in the spirit of free speech or take them to task by asking for a simple qualification then we are in big trouble. Essentially the art of the 'critique' is predicated on one backing their position up. If you think the Olympics is about amity and kindness you Darryl are sadly mistaken. Yes - other ways of expressing himself. It was a T-shirt Darryl for petes sake. AS for my work and the rigour that goes into it day in day out can i suggest Darryl me old china you get your spell check on and check your grammar. It is the least the people of the nation could ask for given your status as a health care professional.
darryl coulstock
registered nurse
Is attack the the only recourse? My point demonstrated!
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Darryl it really is a bit precious to accuse someone of not being up to scratch, an 'attack' they instigate, then not butter up - the only thing it demonstrates is you can dish but not take.
darryl coulstock
registered nurse
sean, i clearly stated that if you, as a professional researcher could not come up with an alternative, other than negative ways, to show cultural identity then you needed to look harder. as an educated man you should assisting to find ways that put aboriginal identity forward in a positive way. when cathy freeman showed the aboriginal flag it was after the event and she combined it with the australian flag. this shows respect. to not wear the uniform at the start, for many people, showed disrespect and put it in a bad light. i did not pick at the way you wrote your piece like you did to mine as this is an infantile means of attack. by all means critique what i say not the manner in which it is transported! there are many people of aboriginal descent who have grammer and spelling difficulties, do you attack them for their errors and grammatical mistakes and think less of there comments also?
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Darryl I was simply making the point - that to throw stones first one needs to be free of failings in the first place. An existential impossibility. I would expect nothing less from any of my students that if they would be critical I would ask them to be proactive in trying to provide examples from off there own bat to get the conversation started. Aboriginality is by its nature self determining would you not agree? - Freeman and Hooper have essentially done the same thing imo, just in different sequences. Freeman in 2004 actually had only the Aborignal flag for memory and copped it big time. Hooper was just sticking up for himself and his mob, nothing more or less. All i asked of you was to provide an example - one example, not really too much to ask when you take my academic credibility to task and say I need to look harder or work more. Then to fold in Aboriginal literacy as a means to make a point was really odd.
John Passant
Graduate Teaching Fellow
Here's what I wrote in ending an article on Damien Hooper on my blog:
'Damien Hooper, whether he realises it or not, has given us a glimpse of an alternative future where our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander brothers and sisters can be proud of their history and their resistance and join with the exploited working class in a new society of freedom and equity where their history and culture is celebrated and respected, not repressed and hidden away.'
Here is the link to the full article if anyone is interested. http://enpassant.com.au/2012/07/31/damien-hooper-is-a-champion/
Gil Hardwick
Anthropologist
Working around the trolls, Sean, I simply wanted to give you 10 ticks for your piece.
First class commentary . . .
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Thanks Gil - all the best
John Passant
Graduate Teaching Fellow
Sorry Sean, I should have first said thanks for raising the issue of the silencing of our Aboriginal history and voices.
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
No need to apologise John - have a good day and may your footy team win unless it is West Coast Heaveho
Rajan Venkataraman
Citizen
Thanks for the article Sean. What strikes me every time these things happen isn't so much that there is "no understanding of aboriginal history" (as per Tatz) but there seems to be an almost equal lack of empathy for actual aboriginal people. Even if we disagree with the actions of Hooper or Freeman or Winmar, can't we also ask ourselves the question: how would I feel if I were an aboriginal person toward a flag bearing the union jack? Would my identification with it be less than total? Would I have…
Read moreSean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Rajan - empathy is the key - aka the Redfern speech - great points and great insight. thanks SG
Nick Hatzoglou
Sports Administrator
From Fear of a Brown Planet Aamer Rahman & Nazeem Hussain
Every few decades, something interesting happens in sport.
Black Salute, Nicky Winmar, Cathy Freeman and now Damien Hooper.
The Olympics are so awesome. A tournament where an Aboriginal man has to promise not to wear the flag of his people, while competing for the colony that killed his ancestors, in the heart of the empire that stole his country. Gives you that warm, fuzzy feeling.
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
Thanks Nick
Kitty Te Riele
CRN Principal Research Fellow at Victoria University
Perhaps Indigenous athletes could argue they should be allowed to compete under the olympic flag because the AOC does not represent them?!
eg. see https://theconversation.edu.au/doing-it-for-themselves-being-an-independent-olympic-athlete-8553
That might send a message to Australians - esp. if they went on to win gold ...
Nick Hatzoglou
Sports Administrator
Red Elephant Project@redelephantaus
Damien Hooper - When this loss is long forgotten your statement will live on. Good luck continuing the proud Aboriginal pro boxing tradition
Philip Dowling
IT teacher
I presume that it his non-aboriginal genes that caused this loss.
http://www.boxingscene.com/damien-hooper-announces-pro-run-olympic-loss--55715
Sean Gorman
Research fellow at Curtin University
That really is a sad and unnecessary comment Philip and coming from an educator only amplifies its sadness.
Philip Dowling
IT teacher
I refer you to Anthony Mundine's comments.
As an educator I prefer to give my students the whole truth not a censored, gilded, gelded version of it.
Matthew Klugman
Research Associate of the Institute of Sport, Exercise and Active Living at Victoria University
Great piece Sean, it's well past time for the AOC to allow and better still support actions like these.