Decline in young male suicide hides rise in remote areas

A sharp decline in the overall suicide rate among young Australian men has masked a rise in remote areas and low socioeconomic groups, according to a series of papers examining global trends in suicide. The papers, published in The Lancet today, consider a variety of factors that have contributed to…

Wrx69yz2-1340331705
Better treatment for depression will reduce suicide rates, experts say. Flickr/aouniat

A sharp decline in the overall suicide rate among young Australian men has masked a rise in remote areas and low socioeconomic groups, according to a series of papers examining global trends in suicide.

The papers, published in The Lancet today, consider a variety of factors that have contributed to a 60% global increase in suicide over the past 45 years. “To voluntarily end one’s own life is incomprehensible for most of us,” write Michael Lewieck, a Clinical Assistant Professor of Medicine at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine, and Sara Miller, a Research Fellow in Genetics at Harvard University.

“In The Lancet, three reviews help us to better understand the incomprehensible, each with the aim of contributing to strategies to reduce the risk of self-destructive behaviour.”

One of the reviews, which addresses the issue of suicide in young men, notes that a series of studies have shown that rural or remote residence increases the risk of suicide among that group in Australia.

Between 1999 and 2003, the rate of suicide among young men in remote areas of Australia increased from 38.8 per 100,000 to 47.9 – a 23% rise.

“The overall decline in suicide rates for Australian men aged 20—34 years (from 40 per 100,000 in 1997—98 to 20 per 100,000 in 2003) masks the continued rise in suicide rates in young men in remote areas, as well as in lower socioeconomic groups,” the report says.

“Explanations relate to the migration of healthy workers to cities, and the increasing economic disparity between men in rural and urban areas. In relation to marital status, evidence from high-income countries shows that marital status in men interacts with age, such that being separated increases suicide risk in young men to a greater extent than in older men.”

By recognising depression faster and treating it more effectively, communities across Australia could drastically reduce suicide rates, said Gavin Andrews, a Professor of Psychiatry at the University of New South Wales at St Vincent’s Hospital.

“Isn’t it time we tried to stop suicide by turning off the depression?” he said.

In a study of 300 people being treated for depression, Professor Andrews found that the total number of days in which patients said they would be ‘better off dead’ fell from 1032 before treatment to 496 after. “The drop in ‘better off dead’ days was greatest in the most severe – a drop of 65% in those who originally thought about being ‘better off dead’ more than half the time,” he said.

“Shouldn’t we be treating those at risk of suicide and reducing access to the means to commit suicide?”

Keith Miller, a Senior Lecturer in Social Work and Social Planning at Flinders University, said suicide was a deeply emotive issue that had a horrendous impact on many lives. “Suicide in rural and remote communities is a public event,” Dr Miller said. “Everyone hears about it and has an opinion.

“Australia is similar but also unique amongst developed nations. Often it is a range of reasons which lead to someone engaging in self-harm or completing suicide. We must not perpetuate the myth that suicide is shameful and needs to remain hidden.

“Suicide prevention strategies are available to varying degrees around the country. We need to ensure that our most vulnerable young people are able to access these strategies.”

If you or someone you know needs help, contact Lifeline’s 24-hour helpline on 13 11 14, SANE Australia on 1800 18 7263 or the Beyondblue Info Line 1300 22 4636.

Sign in to Favourite

Want to follow The Conversation?

Sign up to our free newsletter to get the day's top stories in your inbox each morning, with a special wrap on Saturday.

Spinner
Donate and become a friend of The Conversation

Join the conversation

6 Comments sorted by

  1. David Thompson

    Research Officer In Men's Health at University of Western Sydney

    Thank you for raising this issue and drawing attention to its causes and effects. If anyone is interested in some of the insights of men or their surviving families of suicide and its related causes, I would recommend having a look at MHIRC's report 'Pathways To Despair - The Social Determinants of Male Suicide' at http://www.uws.edu.au/mhirc/mens_health_information_and_resource_centre/publications#pathways.

    Compelling reading.

    report
  2. Dale Bloom

    Analyst

    Various research seems to indicate that an accumulation of stressful life events can result in poor physical and mental health, and possible suicide.

    A stress scale, such as the Holmes and Rahe stress scale could be valuable in identifying the most likely stressful events.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holmes_and_Rahe_stress_scale

    report
    1. James Walker

      logged in via Facebook

      In reply to Dale Bloom

      Oh, that takes me back! When I was working in a public service debt recovery section, we were made to take a variant of this test - none of us scored less than twice the 'dangerous' level. We laughed about it at the time, but it's no wonder we were all insane.

      report
  3. John Mendoza

    Adjunct Associate Professor at University of Sydney

    Thanks for taking up this issue. We need to continually shine some light on suicide and suicide prevention in Australia. It is woefully funded and we lack a coherent, assertive and effective national policy response.

    It is common to see headlines pointing to a "significant decline in suicide amongst young men" in Australia. There are several problems in reaching this conclusion including:
    1. The ABS data is unreliable, particularly in the early 2000s. Drawing any solid conclusions is fraught…

    Read more
  4. Gil Hardwick

    Anthropologist

    It continues to bother me that simple loneliness is so often missing from these discussions, in favour of some new psychological diagnosis still presupposing the oddly contradictory notion of individual in a gregarious species as humans.

    As many point out, social isolation, disconnectedness, want of personal networks, may not directly contribute to suicide or other form of early death, but there is certainly strong evidence to suggest that it does contribute to inadequate diet, poor personal care…

    Read more
  5. Anne Collins

    Former IT Manager

    With regards to the significant changes to things like Workcover laws in NSW and the number of men injured on the job and then losing them I wonder if anyone has looked at this as a cause of sucide or even examied it as a stand alone study. I remember some men being interviewed in those circumstances and two saying it had affected them enough for some attempts
    Does anyone know of such research as i would like to read anything on the subject or the statistics,

    report