Sections

Services

Information

UK United Kingdom

History mystery solved: the origins of the Falkland Islands wolf

A long-standing natural history mystery has been solved, as my colleagues and I explain today in the journal Nature Communications. The Falkland Islands wolf, or warrah, may have been the world’s loneliest…

The Falkland Islands wolf was marooned for thousands of years before going extinct. Michael Rothman for Ace Coinage, Inc

A long-standing natural history mystery has been solved, as my colleagues and I explain today in the journal Nature Communications.

The Falkland Islands wolf, or warrah, may have been the world’s loneliest land mammal. It was marooned for thousands of years on the wind-swept Falkland Islands with only seabirds, penguins and seals for company.

These animals represented an enigma to early explorers, scientists and natural historians. Charles Darwin, the father of the theory of evolution, visited the islands in 1834 and mused on the origins of this odd creature.

How did a medium-sized mammal make the 460km journey from the South American mainland, and why was it the only land mammal to have done so?

Sadly, like the Dodo and Tasmanian tiger, the Falkland Islands wolf was hunted to extinction within 200 years of discovery. The last animal was killed 40 years after Darwin’s visit to the islands taking the secret of its origins with it. In the 130 years since, the origins of the Falkland Islands wolf have been a mystery, providing many more questions than answers:

  • Did the ancestor of the warrah make a miraculous sea journey on ice floes or rafts of vegetation blown off the South American mainland by the prevailing westerly winds?
  • Did it walk there via a land-bridge during lowered sea levels in ice ages?
  • Was it carried there as a semi-domesticated companion/hunting animal by the first human occupants of southern South America, some time in the last 10,000 years?

Stanley, Falkland Islands. Skinnyde

Cracking the riddle

In our Nature Communications paper, myself and colleagues from the University of Adelaide (Alan Cooper, Julien Soubrier), Argentina (Fancisco Prevosti, Luciano Prates, Valentina Trejo), and Chile (Franciso Mena) detail the work we did.

We pieced together the puzzle using new data from genetics, fossils and oceanography and discovered the ancestor of the warrah probably walked to the islands across a frozen, narrow marine strait during the last ice age, about 16,000 years ago.

Working in our specialist, ultra-clean-room ancient DNA laboratory we carefully extracted DNA from museum specimens of the Falkland Islands wolf and subfossil bones of an extinct South American wolf.

The extinct mainland wolf provided the first key to solving the riddle. Without these samples from the most-likely mainland source population it’s almost impossible to say anything about the origin of the island species.

Using DNA from these two extinct species we were able to show they were very closely related. Determining how close was the key to identifying when the ancestor of the warrah reached the Falkland Islands.

Using new mathematical techniques to estimate a “molecular clock” we calculated the age of the split between the mainland fox and the warrah to be around 16,000 years ago, much more recently than previously thought.

Importantly, this date is before the arrival of humans in South America, some 12,000 years ago. If humans didn’t carry the ancestor of the warrah to the islands, how did it, and only it, make this long voyage across inhospitable oceans?

Falkland Islands. Wikimedia Commons

Thanks to new oceanographic information, we know the Falkland Islands weren’t always as isolated from South America as they are today. At the height of the last ice age sea levels were up to 130-150 metres lower, exposing an enormous coastal plain off the Argentine coast.

Falkland Island fox or “Antarctic Wolf” by John Gerrard Keulemans,1890. Wikimedia Commons

The Falkland Islands also quadrupled in size. As a result the marine strait separating the two shrank dramatically, potentially to just 20-30 km. The remaining stretch of water would also have been much shallower.

It seems likely that under the cold conditions of the last ice age this strait could have periodically frozen over, creating a brief window of opportunity for a cunning fox to reach new land.

The absence of any other land mammals on the Falkland Islands suggests the connection with the mainland must have been brief and relatively inhospitable. Acting as a filter, rather than a corridor, periodic icy connections would have discouraged dispersal by most land mammals, leaving the Falkland Islands wolf “home alone”.

Of course, the warrah’s 16,000 year isolation contributed to its eventual demise. Like many island species, it was totally naive to predators - including humans - and was easily killed by early European settlers.

For the warrah, the Falkland Islands turned from an ark to an executioners chamber in less than 200 years.

Articles also by This Author

Sign in to Favourite

Join the conversation

6 Comments sorted by

  1. Sean Lamb

    Science Denier

    Provided yoiur molecular clock is as firmly based as you believe then the conclusion must be sound.
    The presentation of the size of the gap that would need to frozen over is a little vague in this article.
    Would they be travelling via the Burnwood Banks? The Malvinas Basin itself seems quite deep.

    report
  2. David Paxton

    Veterinarian

    Jeremy, sorry to come in so late on an interesting article. The two extinct species you refer to, were they foxes or wolves? And are you able to tell by molecular biology whether the population had sufficient genetic diversity to thrive? If it did, you would think there would be so much food and so few predators that the population would have been large. Predators seem to be more wary that flocking or herding animals (presumably like the Dodo). Thanks and best wishes.

    report
    1. Jeremy Austin

      Deputy Director and ARC Future Fellow, Australian Centre for Ancient DNA at University of Adelaide

      In reply to David Paxton

      Hi David, they were fox-like wolves or wolf-like foxes! The genetic diversity of both species was reasonably low. Despite the size of the islands, the food resources would have been reasonably seasonal so not sufficient food for large populations to exist.

      report
    2. David Paxton

      Veterinarian

      In reply to Jeremy Austin

      Thank you Jeremy. I wonder, in your studies on ancient DNA, whether you are working on the dingo. I have a hunch that the dingo/dog came to Australia magnitudes longer ago than the consensus position (5000 ya). If humans were here 60,000 ya it seems to me logical that they would bring the dog as a food source and sentinel, but the two species dis-associated in the novel marsupial environment. It also seems to me that if humans were living along the sea shore since their evolution, they would have developed maritime skills very early. It seems very unlikely that the dingo/dog would cross to Australia/New Guinea other than by being carried, whether it came from India, Indonesia or Taiwan. Do you have an opinion on this, please?

      report
  3. Dave McRae

    logged in via Twitter

    Thanks Jeremy. Most interesting article

    report
  4. Ben D. Shiriak

    logged in via Facebook

    "Arrival of humans in South America 12,000 years ago."

    Numerous sites push this date much further back. Pedro Furada, for example.

    report