Menu Close

Brain Gaines

Sleep deprivation is dangerous, but especially behind the wheel

Bad for you, bad for everyone else. Shutterstock

The National Sleep Foundation has done a great job terrifying citizens since the 1990s with its annual Sleep in America poll results. In 2005, 60% of adult drivers in the US reported that they’d driven a vehicle while drowsy in the past year, and 37% said they had actually fallen asleep at the wheel. Startlingly, 11m drivers (4% of the population) admitted to an accident or near-accident from actually dozing off at the wheel.

The outrage surrounding a crash that critically injured 30 Rock comedian Tracy Morgan is for good reason. The multi-vehicle accident also killed comedian James McNair and injured several others. Kevin Roper, whose Wal-Mart truck struck Morgan’s limousine bus on the New Jersey Turnpike early Saturday morning, had reportedly not slept for over 24 hours when the crash occurred. Roper denied these claims, pleading not guilty during his arraignment.

Driving while sleep-deprived is such a terrible idea that it raises the question of why anyone would attempt it in the first place. But while study after study confirms that Americans are sleepier than ever before, nearly one in ten of us also commutes an hour or more to work everyday. Add in the stress of finances, parenting, maintaining a social life, and trying to fit in a few minutes of exercise, it’s hardly surprising that drowsy driving is commonplace.

A study published last year in PNAS reveals the grim truth behind why sleep deprivation makes us feel so terrible physically, mentally, and emotionally. In short, insufficient sleep affects every major organ system in our bodies.

The researchers, from the University of Surrey, took blood samples after 26 participants sleep-deprived themselves for one week (sleeping 5.7 hours on average), followed by one week of sufficient sleep (8.5 hours). By performing what’s called a transcriptome analysis, the authors were able to determine which genes were being transcribed from DNA into RNA, the template for synthesising new proteins. Amazingly, insufficient sleep caused a change in the rate of transcription in 711 different genes, many of which are implicated in circadian rhythms, oxidative stress, and metabolism.

Research by Mark Chattington of Manchester Metropolitan University has demonstrated that a night of total sleep deprivation (as prosecutors claim Kevin Roper experienced) affects a person’s ability to coordinate eye movements while driving. In his study, six participants steered a driving simulator for one hour at 5pm (about the time when folks start heading home from work). After staying awake all night, participants repeated the simulation at 5pm the following day. By measuring their eye movements through a tracker mounted on the dashboard, Chattington and colleagues found that both the co-ordination and speed of eye movements were reduced.

Other work by Alexandros Vgontzas and colleagues at Penn State College of Medicine even suggests that one week of mild sleep restriction to six hours per night – something that 40% of Americans report experiencing – significantly reduces attention and reaction time in a simple computer task. Alarmingly, even three nights of recovery sleep designed to mimic the weekend, which allowed ten generous hours in bed, did not improve performance on the task.

Legally, US truck drivers are not supposed to drive more than 11 hours each day without resting, nor work more than 14 hours per day (including driving and non-driving). Depending on the employer, the current limit is 60 or 70 hours a week. A controversial new proposal being reviewed by Congress, however, would allow truck drivers to log as many as 82 hours per week.

Under New Jersey law, where the weekend’s multi-vehicle crash occurred, a driver can be convicted if there’s proof he or she hasn’t slept for 24 hours, which can result in five to ten years in prison. The investigations into Roper’s state at the time of the accident continue.

Sleep loss does nasty things to our bodies. But if you’re sleep-deprived while steering a 15-ton, 70 mile-per-hour bullet down a crowded stretch of highway, you’re capable of doing terrible things to the unsuspecting bodies around you, too.

Want to write?

Write an article and join a growing community of more than 133,900 academics and researchers from 4,161 institutions.

Register now