Menu Close
Four men seen performing on stage with microphones, one in a t-shirt that says 'Wu-Tang'
Now and Then finds a place alongside Beatles’ songs like We Can Work it Out or Girl which move between major-key and minor-key sections. A still from the song’s video. (YouTube)

Now and Then: How composition choices made John Lennon’s music memo into a Beatles song

The Beatles’ “last song ever,” released 61 years after their first single, was bound to be significant.

But how did John Lennon’s lo-fi, 40-something-year-old cassette recording of Now and Then — deemed “fucking rubbish” by George Harrison during the failed 1995 attempt to revive the song — become an instant No. 1 chart hit and worthy addition to the Beatles’ catalogue in 2023?

Beyond the AI-assisted salvage of Lennon’s voice from the noisy cassette, it is worth examining Lennon’s raw materials, and the strategies that made the unfinished late-1970s musical sketch a Beatles’ song.

Now and Then official music video.

Personal music memo

Had Harrison told Lennon himself that the song was rubbish, Lennon might have responded, “Well I’m not finished with it yet, am I mate?”

Lennon’s original “demo tape” was not made for formal presentation (to a music publisher, for instance).

It was a personal memorandum to capture basic song ideas — something musicians do all the time. If they stopped there, Yesterday would be Scrambled Eggs, and the Rolling Stones’ Satisfaction would be one minute of Keith Richards’s signature riff and 45 minutes of snoring.

Unorthodox compositional form

The surviving two Beatles decided to finish the song in 2023, bringing in producer Giles Martin, son of George, the celebrated fifth Beatle, and incorporating Harrison’s guitar parts from 1995. The lyric sheet from these sessions, marked up by producer Jeff Lynne, suggest Lennon hadn’t titled his song-in-progress.

What likely bothered Harrison most about Lennon’s recording was its unorthodox application of verse-chorus song form. In verse-chorus form, the chorus typically provides the main “hook.”

Verse-chorus songs occassionally feature a “pre-chorus,” which follows the verse to set up the chorus.

Text of the song _Revolution_ showing how the verses and pre-chorus are arranged.
The pre-chorus in Revolution begins: ‘But when you talk about destruction ….’ (Steven Baur), Author provided (no reuse)

Another section common in verse-chorus songs is the bridge, usually a contrasting musical idea introduced only after the verse and chorus.

Text of the song _Here Comes the Sun_, showing how the bridge of the song is introduced after the verse and chorus.
In Here Comes the Sun, the bridge is the part that goes, ‘Sun, sun, sun, here it comes.’ (Steven Baur), Author provided (no reuse)

Delayed chorus

On Lennon’s recording (heard in this musician’s video), Lennon introduced a bridge-like section where a pre-chorus would normally go. But rather than propelling the song toward the chorus, it meanders awkwardly, delaying and undermining the arrival of the chorus hook.

John most certainly would have revised this. In his absence, Martin and the remaining Beatles opted for the only solution available: cutting Lennon’s misplaced, unfinished pre-chorus/bridge and composing a new bridge.

Two columns reading _Now and Then_ cassette version and _Now and Then_ single version seen side by side. Text of the songs show both versions have two verses in A minor, but the first version goes into a pre-chorus bridge and the second version goes into a chorus.
The structure of Lennon’s Now and Then and the finished single seen side by side. (Steven Baur), Author provided (no reuse)

Most Beatles’ songs in major keys

Now and Then plays on the contrast between major and minor tonalities. Major keys are commonly described as “bright” or “happy,” while minor keys are often described as “dark” or “sad.”

Major-key songs dominate the Beatles’ catalogue, comprising roughly 81 per cent of their recordings. Only four per cent remain entirely in minor keys, including Come Together and I Want You.

Now and Then is among the remaining 15 per cent of Beatles’ songs that move between major-key and minor-key sections, alongside We Can Work It Out or Girl.

Lennon’s verse for Now and Then is among the most minor-laden sections of any Beatles song, opening with alternating minor chords. Mired in minor darkness, Lennon engages a harmonic sleight of hand reminiscent of Beethoven or Schubert, shifting abruptly to a major-chord refuge (on the sixth scale degree). But this ray of brightness is illusory; listeners feel the inevitable pull back to minor-key darkness.

The sound of nostalgia?

As musicologist Susan McClary explains, this particular compositional strategy evokes “Never Never land.”: it “variously radiates hope, escape or nostalgia for a lost arcadia … but it takes only a half-step drop in the bass to return the piece to harsh, unmerciful reality.”

Lennon’s melody and his descending opening phrases strongly imply a melodic resolution to the home pitch (A). Following the aforementioned glimmer of major-chord brightness (on “make it through”) and its slide down to the E dominant chord (“it’s all because of …”), Lennon pauses dramatically.

Four men seen in slim suits in front of a white car.
The Beatles, from left, John Lennon, George Harrison, Ringo Starr and Paul McCartney arrive in Liverpool, England in July 1964, for the premiere of their movie A Hard Day’s Night. (AP Photo)

Finally, Lennon intones the last word (“you”) over the inevitable return to A minor. But rather than the expected melodic resolution down to the home pitch, Lennon clings hauntingly to a dissonant note (B) one step above, before ending with “you-ooh-ooh-ooh” — a trademark vocal ornament.

Seeking relief in the chorus

Pop convention would grant a major-key payoff at the chorus, but Lennon’s pre-chorus/bridge thwarts any such gratification. So the 2023 Beatles cut it, opting for a conventional move directly to the major-key chorus.

The reward is bittersweet. Rather than moving upward to the stable, conventional major key alternative (the so-called relative major), the chorus falls a whole step to G major. Lennon’s melody seeks to ascend, but the melodic leap (on “I miss you”) is tinged by a passing minor chord (a common strategy to evoke longing, as in the opening melodic leap of the classic Over the Rainbow.)

This is not the magical moment we have so often experienced with the Beatles, Beatle-esque strings notwithsanding. Rather than transcendence, fond remembrance settles into resigned acceptance.

Now And Then - The Last Beatles Song (Short Film from The Beatles).

Admirable guitar tribute, but not Harrison

The transcendent gesture comes with the newly composed instrumental bridge, which does move up to the satisfying relative major. McCartney’s soaring slide guitar is a beautiful invocation of Harrison’s melodic sense and phrasing. But it is unmistakably not the Beatles’ late, inimitable guitarist. It is hard not to hear this loss in McCartney’s tribute.

Equally painful is the impossibility of Lennon and his bandmates working his pre-chorus/bridge section into the song. It contains some of the most expressive moments on Lennon’s recording.

Their last song offers a real experience of a glorious past, but makes painfully audible what has been lost.

Want to write?

Write an article and join a growing community of more than 191,100 academics and researchers from 5,061 institutions.

Register now