As doctors across Canada receive COVID-19 vaccines, many are sharing photographs on social media to inspire hope and to encourage others to get vaccinated too.
This has sparked a controversy around “vaccine selfies,” as other doctors say the pictures provoke anxiety, anger and envy.
Studies over the past decade have demonstrated links between browsing social media and depressive symptoms, especially when online content triggers envy. And during the COVID-19 pandemic, vaccine envy is inevitable, with vaccines being limited and the pandemic continuing to rapidly grow.
Social media triggers
For some health-care workers, social media selfies are an unwelcome trigger.
“Social media is complicated,” says Amelia Yip, a cardiologist in Waterloo, Ont., who recently received her first dose vaccine. “Even within the health-care profession, there are people who should be getting it before others. But the way it’s being rolled out doesn’t always work that way.”
“The way the distribution is happening, it feels like there isn’t a co-ordinated effort. It feels under-appreciative for health-care workers, or even those at risk, not just doctors,” says Yip.
Canada’s vaccine rollout has been highly variable between provinces. In Ontario, for example, almost 19 per cent of vaccinated people have completed both doses, compared to only 1.5 per cent in British Columbia.
Yip says there are pockets of people who have been missed in her local rollout, and that at her hospital, cardiologists had to remind authorities that they, too, are involved in critical care.
Meanwhile, says Yip, it’s been doubly frustrating to see vaccine selfies posted by people who don’t work on the frontlines.
“Yesterday, a completely non-medical person who’s an accountant and happens to work at a Toronto hospital got it. When you see someone not even working [with COVID-19 patients] getting it, it feels like the person is jumping the queue.”
Anger and resignation
Alan Drummond, an emergency physician in Perth, Ont., where frontline workers are still waiting for word of vaccines, says:
“You have to take the broader context to understand where some of the disappointment and anger is coming from. For at least 10 months, ER physicians and nurses were dealing with a novel virus that has the potential to be quite deadly. I don’t know anybody in my sphere who shied away from the responsibilities of looking after patients — nobody.”
Drummond says the initial arrival of vaccines in Canada was met with hope and enthusiasm, and that it was “entirely appropriate” that doctors celebrated on social media as a sign of the beginning of change.
But as selfies continue to get posted online, Drummond says he and his colleagues are beginning to feel resigned and angry.
“The inequities are starting to show…. We need an appropriate queue — we certainly aren’t in it. And [the selfies are] the icing on the cake.”
Impacts of stress
Stress due to providing care to coronavirus patients has significant consequences. Frontline doctors, nurses and therapists are burned out. Tragically, 35-year-old doctor Karine Dion recently died by suicide. Emergency and intensive care doctors have also reported feeling overwhelmed.
Sarah Giles, a rural family and emergency doctor in Kenora, Ont., says her community will not be receiving vaccines until April.
“When we look at inequalities, we know that there is a lifespan discrepancy between living in northwest Ontario and in southern Ontario. As my friend said, we’re at the end of the supply for fruits and vegetables and you can tell: We’re at the end for vaccines as well.”
And especially in rural communities, says Giles, every health-care worker is paramount.
“We have human resources issues. If we lose a couple of doctors or nurses, it’s going to be a big problem.”
For Giles, who lives alone, vaccine selfies have been personally anxiety-provoking; she says when she gets vaccinated, she will not post a selfie.
As for Drummond, he has this message for doctors: “By all means celebrate, but celebrate privately. Just don’t do it so publicly when a lot of your colleagues who are dealing with this stuff are dealing with their own anxieties and fears. We get it — we’re happy for you. Just don’t rub salt in our wounds.”